Italy's PV program under new management

As a new director, unschooled in renewables, takes control of the Italian PV program at the Ministry of Environment from the man who created it, the future of government-subsidized PV is certain only for 2003.

©   PHOTON International

Axed: Gianni Silvestrini (above), fired as head of the national PV program, helped get PV onto Italian buildings, like this 20 kW Eurosolare S.p.A. installation in Rimini. (right)

Italy's center-right coalition headed by Prime Minister Silvio Berlusconi has finally gotten round sweeping out the old guard in the Ministry of Environment(MdA). Caught in the mid-August was Gianni Silvestrini, the MdA director who had been instrumental in getting the oft-delayed Italian PV roofs program on its feet. Frequently caught between national and regional bureaucracies, Silvestrini had to bear the frustrations of the PV industry as the program struggled to get off the ground (see PI 8/2002, p. 16 and 18). Despite this, the PV community always maintained respect for his knowledge of PV and his devotion to getting it established in Italy.

So far, the same cannot be said of his replacement, Bruno Agricola. Although a longtime employee at the MdA, Agricola has no background in PV and practically none in renewables, according to several sources. »Right now he is studying what a solar system is,« says one member of the PV industry, who requested that his name not be used.

©  Eurosolare S.p.A.;

  A 20 kW Eurosolare S.p.A. installation in Rimini.

For the moment, Agricola's appointment will have little effect on the program. While he performed his first official act in September by releasing extra funds for a smaller part of the program dealing with public projects, the big question revolves around the far larger regional program. Funding for the next phase had already been secured by Silvestrini as one of his last acts, when he signed a decree in July releasing €13.5 million ($13.2 million) of MdA money for the second round, which will be matched by the regions. They are expected to publish tenders in November or December. The real test of Agricola's commitment will come when he decides on €20 million ($19.6 million) for the third phase of regional programs, which had already been placed into this year's budget. For now, it has been delayed – at least until a planned restructuring of the MdA is completed, probably by the end of the year. Even then, says Agricola's assistant Mario Gamberale, it is impossible to guess when funds could become available.

No decisions yet

Agricola, who declined to speak with PHOTON International, attended a closed-door Sept. 20 meeting with the PV industry association GIFI (Gruppo Imprese Fotovoltaiche Italiane) and the heads of several PV companies. According to sources, Agricola, who will head three departments, has not yet decided whether he wants to use the MdA's limited funds to continue the PV program. He has requested that GIFI prepare a document clarifying why PV should be supported. While the willingness to learn is admirable, says the source, Agricola's desire needs to be followed by swift actions.

Interestingly, Agricola's reservations seem to mimic comments made by his boss, Minister Altero Matteoli of the MDA. In late June, Matteoli gave a television interview in which he criticized PV. »In Italy, if we install 10,000, 100,000, or 1,000,000 photovoltaic roofs,« said Matteoli, »the [electricity production] is nearly equal to zero.« While Gamberale admits this is not a hopeful sign, he insists the program is not in danger.

For Silvestrini, the fate of the program depends on whether Agricola keeps a low profile or decides to demonstrate concrete support. At any rate, Silvestrini expects the regional governments, now that they have gotten a taste of PV, to apply »bottom-up pressure« on the MdA to keep the program alive.

But even in the program survives, Emiliano Fioravanti, the head of GIFI, is unhappy that as of July it had only been responsible for 200 kW of installation. Instead, he has been pushing for a feed-in tariff of about €0.50 ($0.49). While Silvestrini supported this concept, there is no word yet from Agricola. And that is precisely what disturbs Fioravanti -- the uncertainty surrounding PV in Italy. »You can't be saying 'yes' today and 'no' tomorrow,« he complains. »We need a very stable picture.« That will undoubtedly have to wait.


William P. Hirshman
© PHOTON International, October 2002